Safe exit

In lived experience partnership work, it is important to be continually reviewing your:

  • processes (how you did what you did)
  • outcomes (what the result was)

While reflecting and making responsive changes.

Note: In this step we use the word ‘review’ – but in some cases and organisations this might be an evaluation process.

Planning your review

When planning your review processes, consider how different voices will be captured, analysed and interpreted, including:

  • lived experience
  • staff
  • facilitator/s.

How could you create opportunities for lived experience partners and/or mentors to help you define what success looks like, and write your review questions? Consider:

  • on what basis the success of the work will be determined
  • how you will know if the project upheld the planned values and principles.

How can findings and recommendations be:

  • integrated into organisational processes?
  • fed back to leadership or management?
  • shared with people outside your organisation?

For reflection

  • What values guided you throughout this work? What has supported you to hold onto those values? Were there any times you were drawn away from those values, and why?
  • What would you do differently next time?
  • Has the work reshaped anything for you?

Reviewing your processes (how you did what you did)

This section will help you to think about ways to continuously seek feedback and respond in real time. Reviewing your processes starts on day one and continues throughout.

Seeking feedback throughout

In addition to regularly checking in with people (in 7. Engaging), anonymous feedback mechanisms encourage honest, genuine and constructive insights, and reduce fear of repercussions (e.g. upsetting others, not being invited back). When seeking to measure partners’ experience of being involved and what you hope to achieve you might like to adapt our feedback questions template your own use. You can send it out regularly to partners so they have multiple opportunities to provide anonymous feedback on their experience of being involved and what you are trying to achieve.

‘I think for me personally, it has been incredibly valuable for the children to see a parent that is actively engaged in the world, that is talking about their experiences openly without any kind of stigma attached to it. So, I think for me, thinking about the impact on my family in terms of my involvement, it was actually really quite a powerful and useful process to go through.’

– Lived experience partner

‘Being involved in lived experience partnerships has, for me, meant some of the impacts are good and some of the impacts are bad. This stuff is emotional work and it doesn’t always reflect well on yourself or your family or the situation that you find yourself in.

‘Going back over old, sad information can be really difficult to hold, and maybe there are other opportunities for going out and doing other things with your life, and yet you find yourself continually coming back in to be engaged in this work, to try and make changes. That does take a toll on your emotional wellbeing.

‘It is something you have to be really aware of. It is not good to always think about the past and to think about the pain, and to relive the pain … You have to be aware of how that might impact on people around you.

‘So, sometimes the impact is not a good impact, and I think we need to be aware of that, but equally not afraid of it. I am still standing. I am still here. I am still enjoying the work. Yes, it can be negative … it can be painful, but it doesn’t mean … that we shouldn’t do this work.

‘If it is fulfilling and if you feel as though you are making a difference, being heard and making a contribution, then the most wonderful thing that you can do with your time, is to be surrounded by people who are working on a mission you feel is important and share.’

– Lived experience partner

Record keeping of engagement activities

Keeping a record of the specific partnership activities undertaken, methods of engagement, number of people involved and hours contributed can give you an idea of how engaged people are, across which projects, and if they return for subsequent activities. This can be part of what you report to funders and your Board, and indicate what might need adapting to increase participation.

A formal evaluation of your lived experience partnerships can be useful if you have the resources.

Reviewing engagement processes

Reviewing how your lived experience processes have enabled multiple voices to engage on multiple opportunities and at multiple levels, can reveal how to move towards effectively and meaningfully embed lived experience engagement within an organisation. Consider if your processes have allowed for the following:

  • Diverse voices contributing: This could involve finding ways for children or people with access needs to participate, as well as voices that you don’t usually hear from.
  • Multiple opportunities to contribute: This might look like brief feedback surveys after each workshop, plus more opportunities to shape direction and priorities or inform the processes of how the work is done.
  • Lived experience voice to inform whole of organisation processes: Such as governance structures or recruitment processes as covered in 2. Organisational preparedness under Embedding processes for lived experience engagement at different levels.

Reflecting

For staff, this review process should be one of rigorous reflection, in which they lean into the self-critique and discomfort required to unlearn oppression and negotiate dynamic power relations. You might like to revisit the self-reflection tool.

Partnering on lived experience projects involves more than ensuring safe group work. Try to understand from people with lived experience if:

  • they completely understood the process they were a part of
  • they were fully informed about the topic and ways to respond
  • they felt able to express their views and values
  • the approach was honoured (i.e. you didn’t call it codesign when it was consultation).

Katrina Armstrong, Executive Officer, MHCA, describes what success looks like from the perspective of a lived experience leader:

‘An example of this work done well is when it is a conversation and they genuinely want to listen to what we have to say. They try and take some of the emotional and mental load. They hear what you say, put it into their words, and come back and check it with us. They go that extra yard on things.

‘Pre-briefs and de-briefs also help. Organisations demonstrating they heard what we said – and even finding the people invisible to us (people with lived experience) in the system to smooth out the pathway ahead.

‘When staff are encouraging, accommodating and responsive. When they have generosity of spirit. And a willingness to bend the rules when needed. Going over and above. Walking the talk at the end of the day.

‘I can describe a good experience on a working group where I felt heard: I felt if I disagreed I could have a conversation offline with staff. They very clearly published the governance model, it was really clear on a structural level. I felt individually heard, they allowed sufficient time, had a good mix of diverse perspectives and representation. I was an equal. It was not patronising. The work was ongoing. Some of it is a bit of a word salad trying to balance competing views, but they did try to reconcile different points of view and that is visible in the outcome. I didn’t get 100% what I wanted, but they did a good job.

‘It is clear that organisations need to find the right people to lead this work. It comes back to values and attitudes.’

Reviewing the outcomes of the project (what the result was)

  • Did your project or engagement activity achieve what it set out to do?
  • Did it have any had unexpected outcomes in addition to or instead of what was planned?

Successful outcomes will look different for different projects and may be influenced by factors outside the project team’s control.

Outcome review methods

The first step is to review your project aim and projected outcomes you initially set. Defining project aims and outcomes is outlined in 3. Choosing your approach and methodology.

Then explore the expected and unexpected outcomes:

  • from different perspectives – lived experience, staff, facilitators, end users experience of the product/service/outcome
  • by evaluating different sorts of data – surveys, focus groups, interviews, group reflection sessions, project data, and organisational data such as client satisfaction surveys and service use
  • in ways that are collaborative – come together to review themes in the data, think about whether you met the original aim of the project, and develop recommendations and implications for future work.

Examples of what successful outcomes might look like

  • Organisations undertaking authentic lived experience partnerships, and people with lived experience noticing that services listen to them and see them as people and not a problem to be fixed.
  • Organisations changing their practice and models, allowing families to access the resources they need and ask for in their lives. When this work is done well, ways of working should shift within organisations.
  • Changes being made or measures implemented which people with lived experience have actively been involved in.
  • The service or product meets the needs of the population it was designed for.
  • Staff attitudes and understanding respect and honour the lived experience of children and families.

Lived experience participants and staff may have other suggestions of what successful outcomes look like.

Some examples of review questions

  • Questions co-designed by the Emerging Minds Family Forum lived experience advisory group, which reviewed both process and outcomes to improve the facilitation, functioning and impact as part of regular monitoring.
  • Focus group questions used for reflecting on the process and outcomes of an Emerging Minds resource development project. These resources were aimed to support families responding to the negative impacts of the social determinants of health. The review had two separate focus groups. One for lived experience co-designers, and one for Emerging Minds staff including the project coordinator, reviewers and communications staff.

Post-project review of processes and outcomes

At the end of a project or significant piece of work, you might like to seek perspectives from both your lived experience partners and staff. You might use the following criteria to review the process undertaken:

  • Inclusiveness: Were the participants representative and were access needs met?
  • Respect: Were there indicators of equal partnerships?
  • Participation: Was the process open, empathetic and responsive? Did people feel heard and were their voices responded to and acted on?
  • Iteration: Did the process allow participants to continually test and generate new ideas to shape and refine the outcome?
  • Outcomes focus: Did the process achieve the desired outcome? Was there collective investment toward the outcome? Was the outcome satisfactory?

‘At the end of the groups I had a Zoom meeting with one of the researchers and she asked me what I thought of the whole thing. She had lots of questions. She was friendly. She asked me if I had any questions. And she reminded me of the next steps because I had forgotten. I got a gift voucher after that.’

– Child co-design participant

To read more about child perspectives on co-design see What makes participation activities work well for children?

Examples of feedback and ways to respond

Emerging Minds’ lived experience partners provided the following feedback examples. The learnings that resulted were used in the development of this toolkit.

Critical feedback examples

Feedback from lived experience partner

The feedback had impact by helping staff to respond as follows

‘Some of the other negative or challenging elements to engagement can just be the ad hoc, sporadic nature of it; so you don’t have that sense of “This is what happens next, and this is what happens next, and I am part of a bigger picture” that most of the staff would probably have a sense of. I think we have a long way to go in terms of lived experience partnerships, but we are on the right track.’ Understand the importance of communicating clearly at the start and throughout a project – and have various ways to do this. Examples are outlined in the following steps:

‘Cramming a lot of content in can be quite exhausting. Not staying on task, which isn’t always easy in a group situation, especially with lived experience.’ Understand the importance of planning engagements well. This means:

  • reaching shared agreement on meeting structure and ways to bring back focus to the project when needed
  • sending out an agenda and pre-reading ahead of time so people have the chance to feel more prepared and ask questions beforehand.

You will find examples of how to do this in 4.1 Beginning the connection.

‘Not enough inclusion in the design of the strategy of the initiative for those of us interested. I would like to have seen us have a rotating position on the Board or some other part of the organisation … It felt like “us and them” at times, with some one or two privileged of “us” being able to participate at another level.’ Reflect on how staff bring themselves to engagements. Examples of this are outlined in 3.2 Ways to engage.

Leadership working to embed processes for lived experience engagement at different levels. This is part of 2. Organisational preparedness.

‘Occasionally I felt disempowered. To lessen the likelihood of this happening again, I feel that it would be helpful for staff to remember to come from a position of wanting to learn from family partners, and not to position themselves as experts.’ Ensure they set up to do this work well. See 4.1 Beginning the connection for suggestions.

Reflect on how they bring themselves to engagements. See 3.2 Ways to engage for suggestions.

‘Some of the more challenging aspects of being involved, particularly in the group work, were working with people who have different understandings of their experiences. Even though we all came to the process with a common experience of distress and adversity in some shape or form, some of us were children or parents experiencing adversity. Some of us were partners. Some of us were people with mental health issues. Some of us were grandparents.

‘And so, once you throw those experiences of distress into the mix and you are having a conversation about something that is reasonably challenging, you then have some people who like to talk a lot about their experiences. Some people who are still angry. Some people who are very distressed, and some people who have had unfortunate experiences with partners or with families in some other way, which can make it very, very difficult to have a conversation.

‘People have different personalities and ways of contributing to the groups. Being open about those differences, being relaxed about those differences, making sure that those differences are managed, is helpful. Nonetheless, I think it is something that we do need to recognise, and we need to be aware of it, and we need to be willing to talk about it together.’

Be reminded of the complexity of this work and of the – often invisible – skills that lived experience partners bring and the emotional load being carried.

Lived experience feedback informs this whole toolkit, which is designed to offer a process for having lived experience partnerships in a respectful, ethical and meaningful way that promotes overall positive experiences and leads to beneficial outcomes.

 

Positive feedback examples

Feedback from lived experience partner

The feedback had impact by helping staff to respond as follows

‘Partnerships have been a place for me to be heard and contribute in a way that I had never thought possible. It provided extra and rich layers to the meaning of my life’s experiences, and was a validating and even a nurturing process.’ Understand:

  • what an overall positive experience of a lived experience partnership might look like
  • in addition to project outcomes, if this work is done thoughtfully, beneficial outcomes for lived experience partners are also possible.
‘I really enjoyed it. It was so worthwhile being able to share my experience in a supportive environment, [thanks to] both the staff and other lived experience members. It taught me valuable skills about resource development, and I felt empowered being able to use my experiences to support other families going through similar things.’ Understand that a supportive environment:

  • is created by both staff and lived experience partners
  • can lead to skill development

can support the sharing of lived experience knowledge in a way that is meaningful and connects to project outcomes.

‘Overall, it was an excellent experience to feel, at my stage of life, that I had a forum; I could give something back of my experience as a child and adolescent that was listened to, understood and valued.’ Reflect that there are ways of hearing from adults about their experiences of childhood that:

  • support project outcomes
  • are meaningful to the people with lived experience who are involved.
‘It was one of the most enjoyable times I have had. Meeting wonderful people and sharing experiences and thoughts. Creating material that has helped many families, and useful tools for clinicians. Created in a way that was relevant and user friendly and in a language that could be readily understood.’ Know that lived experience partners would like this work to:

  • be relational
  • lead to beneficial outcomes
  • be relevant and accessible
  • not exclude people by using jargon.

Subscribe to our newsletters