Safe exit

Remember that this work is more likely to be worthwhile when it is well-planned and adequate time is committed to undertake the process in a considered and reflective way.

Self-reflection

At the start, and throughout this work, how we bring ourselves, where we sit in the world and how we see it, matters.

You might like to start by checking out Emerging Minds’ self-reflection tool, which is designed to support you to reflect critically and work in a way that:

  • is more ethical
  • reduces the chances of negative impacts
  • ultimately leads to better outcomes for children and families.

It might also contribute to you feeling increased meaningfulness and commitment to your work.

Defining your aim and outcomes

Defining aims and outcomes early gives your project clear direction, aligns stakeholders, and sets the foundation for planning, tracking progress and evaluating impact – even if some details evolve over time. It will help to:

  • Clarify the purpose and scope: Set out the project aims and its boundaries (limitations) –even if some details are still emerging.
  • Know your measurable objectives: Decide what the specific goals to track progress and evaluate success are – understanding that not all objectives may be clear at the start.
  • Think about stakeholders: You may not yet know all the stakeholders involved, but consider key groups including children, caregivers, families, practitioners and policy makers.
  • Consider long-term impact: Look beyond immediate outcomes and think about sustainable and meaningful benefits over time.

Honour the approach you choose

All of the following approaches are valuable and offer different possibilities for different contexts.

In some settings, it’s not always possible to have control of the outcomes. Timelines may be tight, and limited, so an extensive co-design process may not always be possible. However, lived experience voices can still be heard and responded to.

It is important to honour the approach you choose and correctly label it.

Engaging as early as possible

Lived experience input is often sought when reviewing resources, services, projects or processes. It might seem reasonable for organisations to incorporate lived experience at this late stage, but doing so can be tokenistic and miss opportunities for rich collaborations. For best practice, and to achieve outcomes which serve those accessing your service, you will need to involve lived experience partners as early as possible.

Seeking the involvement of children and families in the development of your foundational policy documents (in 2. Organisational preparedness) is a great way to set a culture committed to collaboration.

‘While children and families may not necessarily have capacity to be involved in the entire process, they should be involved at the beginning and at key phases along the way. There’s nothing worse than a whole policy being designed and then being asked for feedback.’

– Lived experience partner

You might feel unsure about engaging with people with lived experience early in a project, when you are still trying to figure it out yourself. But this is exactly the time that voices of experience matter.

Involving lived experience as early as possible is one way we can try to address power imbalances through collaboration on:

  • how decisions are made
  • how strategies and agendas are set
  • what mental models or ways of thinking are used and why.

What are your sources of evidence?

Lived experience is a legitimate source of evidence.

  • What are your other sources of evidence?
  • How will you hear from practitioners, researchers and other sectors?
  • What does the literature say?
  • How will you make decisions about the use of these different knowledges?
  • What will you do when perspectives differ?

Remember that when engaging with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, families and children, you need to think about what your role should be (in 2. Organisational preparedness) and your ways of working (in 4. Planning and connecting).

Ladder of participation

  1. Consultation
  2. Collaboration
  3. Co-production (including co-design)
  4. Lived experience-led

Figure 1. Ladder of participation

Figure 4. Ladder of participation

*Organisations may be familiar with or already using this continuum, adapted from and aligns with IAP2 Public Participation Spectrum – IAP2 Australasia.

  • The ladder of participation has four rungs, starting from bottom to top:

    1. Consultation
    2. Collaboration
    3. Co-production (including co-design)
    4. Lived experience-led

You may consider, select and tailor approaches according to your activity or project needs. The chosen approach may depend on factors including the task or activity, timelines, resources and the skills of staff coordinating the project.

Consultation

A consultation approach involves seeking out the perspectives and views of lived and living experience partners and considering them in decisions about your work. Consultations can be held for any of the activities involved, including planning, design and development, review, communications and marketing, and implementation and dissemination.

For example, a consultation approach may involve:

  • seeking partner feedback on a draft product prior to its finalisation and implementation
  • discussing and having a dialogue around an issue or project, with the final decision usually being made by the organisation.

When done well, consultation can be a meaningful process. It can be especially useful when timelines or budgets are tight.

One way to improve the quality of consultation is to work with lived experience partners (ideally those who have lived experience expertise) to design and develop your consultation process, or at a minimum, your consultation questions.

Example of consultation in a family service

The following is an example of what consultation looks like in a family service.

In our service, consultation …

… looks like …

  • reference groups, feedback surveys and online forums

… is useful because:

  • we are able to get diverse opinions
  • we can include people who don’t have systems understanding
  • it is a cost-effective way to get breadth of input
  • minimal support is required

… is challenging due to:

  • restrictive funding and recruitment structures
  • limited structures to provide adequate support
  • lived experience input is only heard in response to already set questions/formats with no opportunity for ongoing influence
  • limited capacity to make radical change or hear dissonant voices
  • managing expectations in a service system that is hard to change.

…. is maximised by using:

  • clear terms of reference and identifying the scope of engagement
  • lived experience to help with design of questions/formats
  • co-production to make sense of input.

We keep a child and family focus through:

  • a foundation of whole-of-family vision and principles
  • reflective practice as a team.

Collaboration

A collaboration approach is more involved. For example, it might involve seeking partner input and feedback regarding project or process conceptualisation, planning, design and development, and finalisation. Lived experience partners usually participate from the beginning of the process. Typically, there is more equality and shared decision-making in a collaborative approach.

Example of collaboration in a family service

The following is an example of what collaboration looks like in a family service.

In our service, collaboration …

… looks like:

  • specific projects which are time limited with clearly defined goals (e.g. website design)
  • resource creation

… is useful because:

  • casual lived experience staff can be involved
  • boundaries and outcomes are easier to define
  • recruitment can be targeted to particular needs/specialisations/age groups

… is challenging because of limits to:

  • structures that provide adequate support
  • breadth of understanding of the whole context (understanding applies only to scope of project)

… is maximised by:

  • clear job descriptions/engagement scope
  • attention/time given to building relationships
  • clear project objectives
  • co-design of project and goals.

We keep a child and family focus by:

  • having whole-of-family vision and principles embedded in project foundations
  • including child voice through focus groups/workshops if appropriate to project scope/audience
  • reflective practice as a team.

Co-production

A co-production approach involves:

  • co-planning
  • co-design
  • co-facilitation
  • co-evaluation.

It is a collaborative approach that integrates various perspectives and experiences to create solutions tailored to users. A focus on relational processes that enable the exchange and balancing of power, knowledge and skills is key.

Co-production is based on the understanding that people with lived experience play an equal role (alongside practitioner knowledge and literature evidence). They should be involved in decisions regarding the conceptualisation, planning, design, delivery and evaluation of projects or processes from start to finish.

‘There has been a ladder of involvement and a variety of opportunities for ongoing participation. And so, when I first started, I just worked on a few projects. I then became part of a national reference group that was populated with a large number of diverse people, all working on the same kind of mission, if you like.

‘I have developed friendships that have evolved and deepened, and enriched me over the years. I have worked on a textbook for mental health nurses. I have co-developed and co-facilitated training sessions. I have been involved in filming, given conference presentations and, more recently, joined the board – so, work to really set the lived experience direction within the organisation and a sense of being able to contribute something towards the change.’

– Lived experience partner

The Agency for Clinical Innovation has some useful information, including a co-design toolkit that demonstrates a step-by-step co-design process and a guide on building capacity for co-design, which includes the following diagram (ACI, 2019).

Figure 2. The co‑design process

The co‑design process (ACI, 2019)

  • A four-stage process shown as a flow diagram: Stage 1 Engage (frame the problem and build a team); Stage 2 Gather (prepare for co-design and learn from lived experience); Stage 3 Understand (identify touchpoints and prioritise opportunities for improvement); Stage 4 Improve (design, test, implement and evaluate improvements). Arrows show the stages are iterative, with impact measured across the process.

If you are undertaking research using a co-production approach, you might find The Australian Eating Disorders Research and Translation Centre Lived experience co-production checklist useful for inviting self-reflection, promoting co-production and creating collective research capacity.

‘When families like us think about co-design, we are thinking that organisations are really interested in understanding that gap between what we experience and what is delivered and working to address that gap. However, I have become aware of a lot of organisations using the language of co-design, and holding workshops to present their material to people for feedback, but not really having a strong understanding of the distinction between consultation and co-design. I have observed that most organisations have come to understand the policy landscape, and to believe that they should be doing this thing called “working with lived experience”, but not resourcing it, not fully understanding it, but calling it co-design when in fact it is not.

‘I think it is probably incumbent upon organisations to develop a much stronger sense of literacy around what this process of co-design is, right through to the spectrum of participation around consultation. Organisations may not always be resourced to do co-design very well, but at least if they are going to do consultation, call it “consultation”. Let’s not over-reach our understandings of what things are and mislead people, and probably inadvertently mislead the organisation as well.’

– Lived experience partner

Example of co-production in a family service

The following is an example of what co-production looks like in a family service.

In our service, co-production …

… looks like:

  • co-facilitation of peer groups and training
  • strategy/policies review and development
  • co-production of new resources and programs
  • co-developing visions, priorities and strategic plans

… is useful because:

  • it allows lived experience input into planning and review
  • lived experience voice is better able to influence change to structures and systems

… is challenging due to:

  • balancing existing roles/workload
  • the need for ongoing funding
  • diversity being hard to build
  • the need to manage expectations
  • limitations of our service system to impact structural and system change

… is maximised by:

  • structures that enable lived experience engagement at all levels of work and attend to power imbalances to support equal influence and opportunity
  • clear job/role descriptions
  • having a memorandum of understanding (MOU)
  • adequate supervision
  • clear lines of accountability.

We keep a child and family focus through:

  • a foundation of whole of family vision and principles
  • creating ways for child voice to inform scoping, planning and reviewing through forums and workshops.
  • reflective practice as a team.

Lived experience led

A lived experience led approach refers to lived experience partners leading projects across all stages and acting as the ultimate decision-makers. The organisation’s staff play a coordination role. These approaches are usually uncommon within most organisations.

Lived experience led practice example

Lived experience led projects occur most often in lived experience led organisations.

LELAN’s Lived experience development and governance project is an example of a project led by lived experience, and co-produced with lived experience partners, from conceptualisation through to delivery.

For reflection

Before you continue, take a moment to reflect on the following questions.

  • Thinking about individual projects in your organisation, where do they sit on the ladder of participation?
  • How can you ensure you are communicating transparently with lived experience partners about the model of participation you are using?
  • How do you monitor the integrity of your approaches?
  • How can you identify if and when you could step up to a higher level of participation?

Next: Lenses to look through

The next resource outlines different perspectives that can help people better understand children, families and lived experience. It encourages reflection, learning and seeing issues in new ways.

Reference

Agency for Clinical Innovation (ACI). (2019). Patient experience and consumer engagement: A guide to build co‑design capability (p. 5). NSW Health.

Subscribe to our newsletters